ALMA Science Advisory Committee
Minutes for ASAC Telecon October 9, 2000
Conference Date: October 09-2000 (Monday)
Here's the dial-in information for the telecon:
Conference Date: OCT-09-2000 (Monday)
Conference Time: 10:15 AM EASTERN TIME
Conference Duration: 1 hr
Service Level: STANDARD
Call Type: MEET ME/DIALOUT
USA Toll Free Number: 888-282-0373
Non-USA Number: +1-712-257-0408
Passcode: 36942
Conference Leader: Mr Al Wootten
The minutes of the September Meeting were approved without comment.
Participants: R. Bachiller, A. Benz, R. Booth, P. Cox, R. Crutcher, N.
Evans, S. Guilloteau, M. Ishiguro, K. Menten, J. Payne, P. Shaver, E.
van Dishoeck, M. Walmsley, W. Wild, C. Wilson, A. Wootten, M. Yun
(1) Report from Berkeley Face-to-Face Meeting
The draft version was briefly discussed, in particular the sections
concerning polarization, site and receivers bands. The possible
extension of band 1 to somewhat lower frequencies was discussed, to
improve overlap with the EVLA and further enhance science capabilities
(particularly Zeeman splitting observations of the 30 GHz transition of
SO) – this will be mentioned in the report. The final version of the
report will be completed on 10th October and submitted in time for the
ACC meeting.
The version distributed by Karl is at Report in postscript; you may also visit it in
HTML .
(2)Receiver Group Reports
W. Wild and J. Payne reported on two recent meetings of the Receiver
Group. At the Cambridge meeting there were three main points: receiver
specs, calibration, and optics. The specs for the HEMT amplifiers
have been revised and now suggest
significantly higher system temperatures
than might be achieved for SIS for Band 3. Because of the
scientific importance of Band 3, the ASAC felt that the implementation
of Band 3 should not be driven by technology but by scientific priorities.
The HFET vs SIS decision for Band 3 is under study; stability and
saturation are also important issues. Concerning
calibration, the receiver group agreed with the ASAC that it was not
worthwhile to include cold loads. E. van Dishoeck raised the issues of
tuning range and switching between sub-bands. W. Wild replied that this
is also under study, and decisions, involving the ASAC, should
be made shortly. From the
optics meeting, J. Payne said that there has been good progress, and a
report will be issued shortly. R. Crutcher asked about off-axis beams
and expressed concern for polarization. W. Wild said that if one
receiver is to be on-axis (as suggested in the Leiden report), it will
add complication and require a re-design. S. Guilloteau commented that
calibration may actually be easier with the mirrors of an off-axis
system. Finally, it was reiterated that the WVR would be uncooled (or
have its own cooling).
This refers to the JRDG summary for their 4th meeting. One outcome
of this meeting was a special receiver optics meeting held at the end of
September in Tucson. Please read James Lamb's Summary of that meeting.
(3)ALG Issues - Evans and Cox, ALG Liaisons
N. Evans and P. Cox reported on the ALG meeting of 11 September. N.
Evans expressed concern about the ALG’s interpretation of ASAC
recommendations on the number of 12m antennas and receiver priorities,
but any misunderstandings should have been clarified by the Berkeley
ASAC report. Brief summaries were given of the ALG discussions on
correlators, the ACA, Japanese news on LMSA, ASTE, receiver and photonic
developments, and steps towards a three-way agreement. M. Ishiguro
mentioned unresolved issues, including the number of 12m antennas and
the capability of the enhanced correlator.
Please read Jaap Baar's material toward a study of the form of the
ACA antennas.
(4) Site Issues
A. Wootten mentioned some studies currently in progress on site issues.
B. Butler and S. Radford are completing comparative studies of the
Chajnantor and Pampa La Bola sites, and G. Delgado has presented a
report on a 52-year climatological study for the Chajnantor area done by
a consultant. A meeting will take place next month in Charlottesville to
review the CBI experience. Reports from all these activities will be
prepared in time for the Morroco meeting on site testing in November.
(5) Next Meeting
The next ASAC teleconference is scheduled for Monday 13th November.